Benelli M2, M2-G1, M4 Tested Head-to-Head: No Malfunctions, Clear Tradeoffs
Three shotguns, three operating systems, one question: which Benelli fits a given shooter's priorities in price, weight, and proven reliability.
Snapshot
GunsAmerica put Benelli's inertia-driven M2 against the gas-operated M2-G1 and the military-proven M4, running several hundred rounds through each. According to the outlet, none of the three malfunctioned during testing, and the M2-G1 posted the fastest split times of the group while costing significantly less than the M4 EXT.
Key points
- M4: GunsAmerica notes it carries the strongest service history and military credentials of the three, built on a gas system with a long operational track record.
- M2-G1: The newer rear-piston gas design reportedly delivered the quickest testing performance while undercutting the M4 EXT substantially on price, according to the article.
- Classic M2: The original inertia-driven M2 remains the lightest of the three and runs clean, per the comparison, without the gas-system maintenance the other two require.
- Reliability: GunsAmerica reports zero malfunctions across several hundred rounds for all three shotguns during testing.
- Ammo caveat: The article states none of the three models reliably cycles very light target loads under 1,000 fps.
Quick take
For readers weighing a home-defense or duty shotgun, the piece frames this less as a single winner and more as a tradeoff: track record versus speed versus weight and cost. GunsAmerica suggests buyers decide based on their own priorities among those factors, along with which ammunition they actually plan to run, since all three have the same floor on light-load reliability.
Read the full story: gunsamerica.com